Skip to main content
Tissquad

COD

How to Reduce COD Refusals: 5 Strategies

Tissquad··Updated October 24, 2026·10 min read

Cash on delivery in Italy is a double-edged sword. On one side, in stores that offer it, almost one order in five is paid on delivery, and in Calabria and Sicily more than one in three (2022 data from an Italian shipping software provider), so not offering it can mean losing a large slice of customers. On the other, the risk of refusal at the door makes every shipment a gamble on margins.

Across all online purchases by Italians, cash on delivery accounts for 1.6%, far less than digital wallets (33.9%) and credit cards (28.6%), according to the NetRetail 2026 survey by Netcomm, the Italian ecommerce consortium. The problem is not the payment method itself but how it is managed. No measured public data shows how many COD packages are refused in Italy. The real number is in your own orders, and that is where you start reducing it.

This guide breaks down the causes of COD refusals, lists the hidden costs, and lays out five concrete strategies to reduce them.

Why customers refuse delivery in Italy

To solve the COD refusal problem, you first need to understand why it happens. The causes fall into four distinct categories, each with different dynamics and solutions.

Fraudulent orders and product testing

Fraud is also part of cash on delivery. This ranges from orders with fake data, invented names, non-existent addresses, to so-called product testing, where the customer orders to see the item in person with no intention of paying. No public data shows how common it is in Italy, and the risk varies a lot from category to category.

There is also organized fraud, with networks of individuals placing multiple orders to different addresses, counting on the fact that many ecommerce stores do not verify orders before shipping them. The cost to the merchant is twofold: lost outbound and return shipping, plus the product locked in the logistics cycle for days.

Impulse purchases and buyer's remorse

Some COD refusals stem from impulse purchases. The customer sees an ad on Instagram or TikTok, orders in the heat of the moment, and a few days later has changed their mind. Unlike prepaid orders, where the completed payment creates a psychological commitment, COD orders have no sunk cost. Refusing the package is as simple as telling the courier "I don't want it anymore."

We have not found any public research measuring how much impulse purchases or late-night orders contribute to refusals in Italy. Break down your own refusals by traffic source and order time, because that is where it shows.

Customer not home at delivery

Some failed deliveries are not intentional refusals. The customer simply was not home. After the number of attempts set by the carrier, the package is held at the carrier's depot, accumulates costs, and is often returned to the sender without the customer ever having seen it.

This problem is amplified by poor pre-delivery communication. If the customer does not know when the package will arrive, they cannot plan to be available.

Shipping data errors

Address errors also play a part: a wrong house number, a different name on the doorbell compared to the order, or an incorrect postal code. A 2025 European report lists an incomplete or inaccurate address among the most common causes of a failed delivery. Without the mandatory step of online payment, which requires verified data, these errors slip through undetected until the moment of delivery.

E-commerce logistics for Italian brands growing online

Warehouse in Campania, shipping across Italy

The true cost of a COD refusal

The cost of a refusal goes far beyond the lost shipment. Every refused order generates five cost items that, combined, erode margins significantly.

Outbound shipping: already spent and unrecoverable. Return shipping: the return to the warehouse. COD collection fee: the carrier's commission for collecting payment, which, depending on the contract, may be charged even when nothing is collected. Depot holding fees: a charge for each day the package is held at the carrier's depot, depending on the contract. Reprocessing: receiving, inspection, and restocking.

The amounts depend on your carrier contracts, and we have not found reliable public averages. Added up, they make every refusal a cost that goes well beyond the lost shipment.

Consider an example with hypothetical figures. An ecommerce business with 500 COD orders per month and a 25% refusal rate loses 125 orders. If each refusal costs it €15, that is €1,875 per month in direct costs. Add the lost revenue: with an average order value of €60, that is €7,500 of lost revenue per month, for an annual impact exceeding €110,000.

Strategy 1: Pre-shipping call center verification

Pre-shipping phone verification is one of the measures recommended by people who work with cash on delivery in Italy, especially for high-value orders. An operator calls the customer to confirm identity, address, and intention to pay on delivery.

How the process works

The order enters the management system and, if it is a COD order, goes on the list of orders to confirm. The operator calls the customer and runs a brief check.

  • Confirmation of name and delivery address
  • Confirmation of ordered product and amount
  • Customer availability to receive during the expected delivery window
  • Correction of any data errors

If the customer confirms, the order proceeds to preparation. If there is no answer, the order is held, and you agree in advance with whoever makes the calls how many attempts to make and what happens next. If the customer says they no longer want the order, it is cancelled before shipping, saving the entire logistics cost.

Measurable results

No public source measures how much confirmation reduces refusals. Measure the result on your own numbers, comparing the refusal rate of confirmed orders with that of unconfirmed ones, and the cost of a call with the cost of a prevented refusal.

The call center also creates an indirect benefit: pre-delivery human contact improves brand perception. The customer feels cared for rather than abandoned after checkout. This can boost loyalty and reduce refusals on subsequent orders as well.

Strategy 2: Order checks and anti-fraud

A first filter is checking every cash-on-delivery order before shipping, with clear rules on address, history, and order value. Some anti-fraud systems give each order a risk score and block the riskiest ones or send them for manual review. If your logistics is outsourced, ask which checks the warehouse runs and which ones are left to you.

Variables analyzed

These systems usually look at address history (how many orders have been refused at that address), phone number history, name-address consistency, order time, order value relative to the category average, device fingerprint, IP geolocation, and checkout completion speed.

For example, a system like this can flag an address with three refusals in the past six months, and give a high risk score to a €200 COD order placed at 3 AM by a new customer with a generic name and a prepaid mobile number.

Impact on refusal reduction

Together with phone confirmation, the checks stop suspicious orders before shipping, and medium-risk orders are handled with targeted verification rather than shipped blindly. How much refusals fall is something you measure on your own data, before and after.

Strategy 3: Faster delivery

The more time passes between order and delivery, the higher the risk of refusal. We have not found any public data measuring by how much in Italy.

The reason is psychological: the more time passes, the more opportunity the customer has to reconsider, find an alternative, or simply forget about the order. The sooner the package arrives, the less time the customer has to change their mind.

Services like Amazon Shipping say they deliver in 24-48 hours, 7 days a week, in the areas their network covers. That applies only to prepaid orders, because cash on delivery is not among the services Amazon Shipping lists. For COD orders, what counts is the delivery time of the carriers that handle cash on delivery. Ask whoever ships for you which carriers it uses for cash on delivery and what delivery times they state for your areas.

Strategy 4: SMS and WhatsApp pre-delivery notifications

Proactive communication helps reduce missed pickups. The cases published by software providers all point in this direction, although there are no independent studies. A well-structured notification flow includes:

  • Order confirmation SMS: immediately after purchase, with product summary and amount
  • Shipping notification: with tracking link and estimated delivery date
  • Pre-delivery reminder: the evening before delivery, with option to reschedule
  • Delivery day notification: with estimated time window

In Italy, WhatsApp is the channel almost all customers already have. It is used by 86.1% of the population and is the most widely used online service (2025 survey by Censis, an Italian social research institute). Open-rate figures circulate without a stated method, and no public source measures the effect on missed pickups. Our guide to WhatsApp Business API pricing in Italy covers the costs and rules of order messages on WhatsApp.

Strategy 5: Micro-deposits

A complementary approach is the micro-deposit: asking the COD customer to pay €1-3 online as an order confirmation, deducted from the total at delivery. This small financial commitment filters out non-serious buyers without eliminating the COD option.

Discounts, free shipping, or gifts reserved for customers who pay upfront are not a safe route, because since 2018 Italian law no longer provides for price advantages tied to the payment method (Italy's Council of State, judgment no. 2733 of 2026). To encourage prepayment, work on trust and on how convenient online payment is.

The integrated approach: combining the five strategies

No single strategy solves the problem on its own, because each one acts on a different cause:

  1. Order checks stop fraudulent orders
  2. Call center verification filters out undecided buyers and corrects errors
  3. Faster delivery reduces buyer's remorse
  4. Pre-delivery notifications prevent missed pickups
  5. Micro-deposits filter out non-serious orders

No public data shows by how much refusals fall when all five are used together. You measure it on your own history, before and after each step.

How Tissquad can help

Tissquad handles logistics for cash-on-delivery orders for ecommerce brands selling in Italy, Italian or foreign, from its warehouse in Campania, near Naples. Before shipping, we check the address and, on request, confirm cash-on-delivery orders by phone, in Italian. In Italy we ship with GLS, Poste Italiane, and Amazon Shipping, choosing the carrier based on weight, zone, and cost. Cash-on-delivery orders go out with carriers such as GLS and Poste Italiane. A refused package costs outbound and return shipping, which is why the checks happen before shipping.

Want to work out where to start with your refusals? Request a call with our team, the first one is free.

E-commerce logistics for Italian brands growing online

Warehouse in Campania, shipping across Italy

Sources

9