Skip to main content
Tissquad

Fulfillment

Ecommerce Returns in Italy: Regulations and Costs

Tissquad··Updated October 24, 2026·17 min read

Returns are the part of ecommerce no merchant wants to deal with, yet no one can afford to ignore. In Italy, according to data from Netcomm, the Italian ecommerce consortium, reported by the newspaper ItaliaOggi, online returns averaged 5.9% in the first half of 2024, peaking at 11% in clothing. Each return has direct costs, from return shipping to warehouse checks, and indirect costs that often go uncounted.

TL;DR: Italian consumer law gives customers 14 days from delivery to give notice that they are withdrawing from an online purchase, and another 14 days to send the product back (Articles 52 and 57 of the Italian Consumer Code, or Codice del consumo). A return costs you return shipping, warehouse checks, and handling, plus indirect costs. But intelligently managed returns become a lever for customer loyalty and value recovery. This guide covers regulations, costs by sector, reduction strategies, and how to turn reverse logistics into an opportunity.

Yet returns are not just a cost. Managed with an efficient system, they become a tool for building customer loyalty, gathering valuable product data, and recovering value that would otherwise be lost.

Return rates by sector: Italian market data

Return rates vary enormously by product category. Knowing your sector's benchmarks is the first step in understanding whether you have a problem or are within the norm.

Benchmarks by sector in Italy (first half of 2024)

SectorAverage return rate
All sectors (average)5.9%
Clothing11%
Electronics and IT8.3%
Food and furniture5%
Publishing3%
Health and beauty1.8%

Source: Netcomm data for the first half of 2024, reported by ItaliaOggi (October 9, 2024). It is a secondary source and does not state the base used for the average. We did not find a more recent edition with figures by sector.

The "phantom cost" of uncalculated returns

Most merchants only calculate the return shipping cost. But the real cost is far broader:

Direct costs (your carrier invoices and warehouse costs show what they amount to in your case):

  • Return shipping
  • Receiving and quality check
  • Restocking or reconditioning
  • Administrative management (refund, communication)

Indirect costs (often not calculated):

  • Lost revenue: the order value that does not materialize
  • Depreciation: a returned product put back on sale sometimes has to be discounted
  • Financial cost: the refund is issued before the product becomes available again
  • Planning impact: returns make demand less predictable
  • Environmental cost: additional transport and potential disposal

The real cost: examples by sector

In the examples, the return rate is the sector average shown above. Orders, average order value, and direct cost per return are assumptions, to be replaced with your own numbers.

Fashion ecommerce (2,000 orders/month, an 11% return rate matching the clothing average, average order €65):

  • Monthly returns: 220
  • Direct cost per return: €14 (assumption, with free returns for the customer)
  • Monthly direct cost: €3,080
  • Monthly lost revenue: €14,300
  • Annual impact: approximately €209,000 in direct costs and lost revenue

Beauty ecommerce (1,500 orders/month, a 1.8% return rate matching the health and beauty average, average order €45):

  • Monthly returns: 27
  • Direct cost per return: €10 (assumption)
  • Monthly direct cost: €270
  • Monthly lost revenue: €1,215
  • Annual impact: approximately €18,000
E-commerce logistics for Italian brands growing online

Warehouse in Campania, shipping across Italy

Regulations: consumer withdrawal rights in Italy

The Consumer Code (Legislative Decree 206/2005)

The right of withdrawal in ecommerce is governed by Articles 52-59 of the Italian Consumer Code, which transposes EU Directive 2011/83/EU. Key points for merchants:

Duration: the consumer has 14 calendar days from receiving the product to communicate their intent to withdraw. No reason needs to be provided.

Communication: withdrawal can be communicated by any means (email, certified email, online form, letter). The merchant must provide a standard withdrawal form, but the consumer is not obligated to use it. For contracts concluded online since June 19, 2026, the store must also offer an online withdrawal function, covered below.

Return: the consumer has 14 days from communicating the withdrawal to return the product. Return shipping costs are borne by the consumer only if the merchant informed them before purchase and has not committed to covering them, as many fashion stores do (Article 57, paragraph 1). If the product is defective or does not match its description, the return is at the merchant's expense under the legal guarantee of conformity (Articles 128, 135-ter and 135-quater).

Refund: the merchant must issue the refund within 14 days of the withdrawal communication, including the delivery costs paid with the order up to the cost of standard delivery (Article 56). The refund may be withheld until the returned product is received or until proof of shipment is provided by the consumer.

Defective products: Withdrawal is not the only way a product comes back. If it is defective or does not match its description, the legal guarantee of conformity applies for two years from delivery (Articles 129 and 133 of the Italian Consumer Code). The customer is entitled to repair or replacement free of charge, shipping included. A price reduction or a full refund, with the product returned at your expense, applies when repair or replacement is not done, fails or is refused, or when the defect is serious (Articles 128, 135-bis, 135-ter and 135-quater). No return fee and no deduction apply to these returns.

Exceptions to the right of withdrawal

The right of withdrawal does NOT apply to:

  • Custom-made or personalized products
  • Perishable products or those with a short expiration date
  • Products sealed for health protection or hygiene reasons and unsealed after delivery, such as lipsticks, toothbrushes, and razors, when once opened they can no longer be put back on sale (Article 59(e)). Touching the skin is not enough, because according to the Court of Justice of the EU a mattress, like a garment, can be cleaned and resold (case C-681/17).
  • Digital content already downloaded
  • Goods whose price depends on financial market fluctuations

Merchant information obligations

The Consumer Code requires the merchant to inform the consumer, before purchase, about:

  • The existence of the right of withdrawal and how to exercise it
  • The withdrawal deadline (14 days)
  • Who bears return shipping costs
  • Conditions for product return, bearing in mind that the customer is liable only for any loss of value caused by handling the product beyond what is needed to try it (Article 57, paragraph 2, of the Italian Consumer Code)
  • Where the right of withdrawal does not apply (for example, to a personalized product), the fact that the consumer will not benefit from it, or the circumstances in which they lose it (Article 49, paragraph 1, letter m, an obligation in force since 2014)

Warning: if the merchant fails to inform the consumer about the right of withdrawal, the withdrawal period extends to 12 months and 14 days from product receipt (Article 53). An information error can prove very costly.

Omnibus Directive: higher penalties since 2023

Legislative Decree no. 26 of March 7, 2023, which transposed the Omnibus Directive (EU) 2019/2161 into Italian law, raised the penalties. Breaches of the information and withdrawal rules are investigated by the Italian Competition Authority (AGCM), which applies the fines set by Article 27 of the Consumer Code (under Article 66). Since 2023 they range from €5,000 to €10 million. In actions coordinated between authorities of several EU countries, the maximum is instead 4% of the annual turnover generated in Italy or in the EU countries concerned, or €2 million if turnover data are not available (Article 27, paragraph 9-bis).

Since June 19, 2026: the online withdrawal function

For contracts concluded online since June 19, 2026, the store must also let consumers withdraw through an online withdrawal function. This is required by Article 54-bis of the Italian Consumer Code, introduced by Legislative Decree no. 209 of December 31, 2025, which transposes Directive (EU) 2023/2673. The rule sets four requirements.

  • The function is labeled with the words "recedere dal contratto qui" (withdraw from the contract here) or equivalent wording, is clearly visible and easy to reach, and stays available for the whole withdrawal period.
  • The customer provides or confirms their name, the details that identify the contract, and the electronic contact where they will receive the confirmation, then sends the statement using a "conferma recesso" (confirm withdrawal) function.
  • The merchant sends, without undue delay, an acknowledgment of receipt on a durable medium, with the content of the statement and the date and time it was sent.
  • The withdrawal is valid if the statement is sent before the deadline expires.

The function comes in addition to the other ways of withdrawing, which remain valid. It is worth testing it on a smartphone before the peak season, all the way to the acknowledgment of receipt. This is the first Christmas with the obligation, and our guide to setting an extended holiday return policy explains how to coordinate the two. This article is not legal advice; if in doubt, ask a lawyer.

How to reduce return rates: 8 concrete strategies

Reducing returns does not mean limiting consumer rights. It means eliminating the causes that lead to returns, before the customer even orders.

1. Detailed and accurate product pages

Some returns stem from products being "different from how they appeared online." To reduce this gap:

  • High-resolution product photos from at least 4-5 angles
  • Product videos showing real dimensions and details
  • Descriptions including exact measurements, weight, and materials
  • Size guides with comparison tables and fit recommendation tools
  • Customer reviews with fit/quality details

2. Anti-damage packaging

Some returns are due to products damaged during transit. Adequate packaging:

  • Protects the product from impacts and compression
  • Is correctly sized (neither too large nor too small)
  • Uses internal protective materials for fragile products
  • Complies with PPWR regulations without sacrificing protection

3. Fast and punctual delivery

The more time passes between order and delivery, the more likely a return can become, because "buyer's remorse" grows with every day of waiting.

Ask whoever ships for you what delivery times their carriers state for the areas where you sell most.

4. Proactive order confirmation

For COD orders, pre-shipping phone confirmation is what practitioners recommend to reduce "doorstep returns" (delivery refusals), especially on high-value orders, although we have not found a public source that measures its effect. But even for prepaid orders, proactive post-order communication reduces customer anxiety and return rates.

5. Advanced tracking notifications

Keeping the customer informed about every shipping phase reduces customer service requests and the likelihood of returns due to "perceived non-delivery." Key notifications:

  • Order confirmed
  • Package being prepared
  • Package shipped (with tracking number)
  • Out for delivery today (with time window)
  • Delivered

6. Clear and visible return policy

Paradoxically, a generous and clear return policy can reduce impulse returns. The psychological mechanism is anxiety elimination: if I know I can easily return, I am more comfortable with the purchase. And it helps sales: in a 2026 European survey, 70.73% of shoppers say they are more likely to buy from stores with easy online returns (a survey by a shipping software provider across eight countries, Italy included, that does not give the Italian figure).

7. Return cause analysis

Every return is a data point. Systematically collect the reasons:

  • Wrong size/fit
  • Product different from description
  • Product damaged
  • Changed mind / no longer needed
  • Late delivery
  • Product defect

By analyzing these causes, you can address root issues. If 40% of returns are for wrong sizing, the problem is in the size guide, not the return policy.

8. Exchange incentives instead of returns

When a customer requests a return, offer as an alternative:

  • Size/color exchange with free and priority shipping
  • Discount voucher for the next purchase
  • Store credit instead of monetary refund

An exchange costs less than a full return (no refund, just the additional shipment) and keeps the customer active.

Reverse logistics as a structured process

Reverse logistics, managing the return flow of products, cannot be improvised. A structured process comprises five phases.

Phase 1: Request and authorization (RMA)

The customer requests a return through a dedicated portal or via email. The system automatically generates a return merchandise authorization (RMA) number and instructions:

  • Reason for return, as an optional question, because withdrawal needs no reason (Article 52)
  • Return label (prepaid or at customer's expense)
  • Packaging instructions
  • Nearest pickup/drop-off point

Phase 2: Return transport

The package is collected by the carrier or delivered by the customer to a collection point. Timelines depend on the carrier and on the service, whether home pickup or drop-off at a locker or collection point.

Phase 3: Receiving and registration

The return arrives at the warehouse. It is registered in the system with:

  • Date and time of receipt
  • Reference to original order and RMA
  • External packaging condition (intact, damaged)

Phase 4: Quality check and classification

This is the most critical phase. The product is inspected and classified:

  • Grade A (like new): intact product, original packaging, no signs of use. Immediate restocking
  • Grade B (reconditionable): minor defects (damaged packaging, label removed). Reconditioning and restocking as "second choice" or at full price after restoration
  • Grade C (not sellable): significant defects, signs of use, incomplete product. Liquidation, donation, or disposal

Phase 5: Refund and closure

The refund is issued via the original payment method. The system updates inventory and the cycle closes. The return data is added to the database for analysis.

Process benchmark: by law the refund must be made within 14 days of the customer notifying the withdrawal, and it can be withheld until the product is back or the customer proves they have sent it (Article 56 of the Consumer Code). Customers, however, expect shorter times: according to figures reported by shipping and returns software providers, published in 2026 and not specific to Italy, they are willing to wait 5.2 days for a refund, while at most companies checks and refund steps add about 8 days. Longer times generate complaints, disputes, and negative reviews.

Returns as opportunity: 5 strategies to recover value

1. "Second life" program

Products returned in good but not perfect condition (Grade B) can be sold in an "outlet" or "second choice" section of the website at a reduced price. This recovers value that would otherwise be lost and attracts a price-sensitive customer segment.

2. Data collection for product improvement

Every return contains valuable information. If 30% of returns for a shoe are for "runs larger than expected," the problem is in the product or the size chart. This data, collected systematically, guides product and communication improvement.

3. Loyalty through the return experience

A return handled quickly, clearly, and without friction is a loyalty opportunity. The return is not the end of the relationship, it is a test of the relationship.

4. Convert returns into exchanges

As mentioned, converting a return into an exchange maintains revenue and reduces costs. An automated system that proposes exchange as the first option (with incentive: free shipping, small discount) can convert some returns into exchanges.

5. Sustainable returns program

Offering a "consolidated return" option (the customer waits to have multiple products to return) or "in-store return" reduces transport costs and environmental impact while generating a positive brand image.

How Tissquad can help

Tissquad handles returns together with the rest of fulfillment, at its warehouse in Campania, near Naples. We recheck returned items and put the intact ones back in stock, so the goods that come back are available for sale again. In Italy we ship with GLS, BRT, Poste Italiane, and Amazon Shipping, and abroad with GLS, FedEx, DHL, and UPS, choosing the carrier based on weight, zone, and cost. Your return policy, refunds, and any deductions for loss in value remain your decisions, to be made under the withdrawal rules described above.

Discover our returns service, read the guide to choosing a fulfillment provider, or request a call with our team, the first one is free.

Frequently asked questions

Am I required to offer free returns?

Not for withdrawals. Return shipping costs are borne by the customer if you informed them before purchase, otherwise they stay with you (Article 57, paragraph 1, of the Italian Consumer Code). Many stores, especially in fashion, offer free returns anyway. For a product that is defective or does not match its description, however, the return is at your expense under the legal guarantee of conformity (Articles 128, 135-ter and 135-quater).

Can I refuse a return if the product has been used?

No, withdrawal remains valid even if the product has been used. The customer may try it as they would in a store. If they go further, for example by wearing a garment to an event (wardrobing), they are liable for the loss in value, which you can deduct from the refund (Article 57(2) of the Italian Consumer Code). It is up to you to document that loss, with photos and an inspection when the item arrives back at the warehouse.

How long do I have to issue a refund?

The refund must be issued within 14 days of the withdrawal communication and includes the delivery costs paid with the order, up to the cost of standard delivery. You may withhold the refund until the returned product is received or until proof of shipment is provided. The refund must be made using the same payment method used by the consumer.

Do returns impact my carrier rating?

Indirectly, yes. A high volume of returns and return shipments increases your overall shipping volume, which can affect negotiated rates. Additionally, returns generate extra warehouse movements. Reducing returns is also advantageous for optimizing logistics costs.

How do I handle returns for COD purchases?

Returns for products purchased via COD follow the same process as prepaid products, with the difference that the refund is usually made via bank transfer (as there is no original digital payment to reverse), with the customer's agreement and at no cost to them (Article 56). The merchant must request the customer's banking details. This process takes longer. Refusals at delivery are a different matter, because the parcel comes back with no refund to issue, and reducing them takes a check before shipping.

E-commerce logistics for Italian brands growing online

Warehouse in Campania, shipping across Italy

Sources

16